The Moscow Appellate Court upheld the recovery of a 4.6 billion ruble penalty under a 2014 state contract from the satellite manufacturer "Reshetnev" at the suit of the Ministry of Defense, reports the "Pravo" portal.
The company was developing a space system consisting of a ground control complex and spacecraft. The contractor failed to complete the work on the project on time, thereby violating the terms of the contract. The customer charged the defendant 4.6 billion rubles in penalties.
Reshetnev noted that they could not perform the work due to the fault of a third party and petitioned for the application of Article 333 of the Civil Code due to the disproportionality of the accrued penalty.
The court of first instance rejected his arguments and fully satisfied the claim. According to the court, the company did not provide reasonable evidence that the accrued amount was disproportionate. The defendant, upon concluding the contract, familiarized himself with its terms, including the amount of the possible penalty.
Reshetnev manufactures satellites for national projects, such as the federal program "Sphere," which includes the "Gonet" (communication) and "Skif" (internet access) groupings.
At the beginning of the year, JSC "Reshetnev" received an order forthe production of only five devices.
Read more materials:
Foreign customer was not satisfied with the color of the Russian Su-34E fighters
Named the key Russian combat aircraft
Su-27 fighter drove away the American F-15 from the Tu-22M3 bomber: video appeared
Now on home
Start of deliveries scheduled for 2027
Over 51,000 new motorcycles were sold in Russia in 2025
The car will take at least a year to assemble
The application's audience has reached 20 million users
The model will be included in the list of cars for taxis, price - from 2.25 million rubles
All parking lots of the "Administrator of the Moscow Parking Space" are connected to the service
The cars will be supplied to the Moscow Transport Service Directorate
Deliveries to India may begin in 2028
The technology provides automated search for all types of defects in power units
The plane flew 500 km, accelerating to 425 km/h
The plant stated that the information about the termination of purchases for models 6 and 8 is not true
Scientists are using the "Ekran-M" installation